Lean Management versus Lean Operations- What's the difference? Why does it matter?

 




When deploying lean I find it helpful to separate the activities into two components: lean operating systems and lean management systems. They both are integral parts of becoming and entity with world class culture and performance.  These terms are used interchangeably in various organizations, but the tools techniques, and applications of lean are different for both components. 

Your lean operating system will consist of tools and activities related with improvement like kaizen, value streams, flow, pull, takt time, time observation, etc. (setting standards and improving standards) Sometimes I find it helpful to think in terms of breakthrough improvement.   The lean operating system should be able to consistently deliver double digit improvement in the areas of staff morale and engagement, quality, lead-time, and cost.

Your lean management system will consist of all the things related to managing and sustaining your lean environment such as visual management, daily huddles, project management, suggestion systems, daily problem solving, cascading audits, leadership standard work, measurement tracking, etc. (maintaining standards).  The management system can be used for delivering incremental improvement. 

The best way to launch lean would be to deliver the management system first, then go into lean operations, but this approach would rarely be successful. Until management sees some results, or potential results from lean improvement (that come from the lean operating system), no one would be interested in performing the level of work required to get the lean management system up and running. Organizations that launch the management system as the primary  or singular approach in their improvement efforts rarely see breakthrough improvements. 

Make no mistake and don't miss this point. To be successful, you need both systems in place and running well. Even when launching lean operations first, the timeline between launching the lean operating system and the lean management system should be very short, like days apart.

In my opinion, most people fail in long term,  sustainable quality improvement (or minimize their results potential) for three reasons;

First, the lean operating system gets all the popular press yet only accounts for 20% of the work. The management system requires 80% of the work and vary rarely gets any press. When is the last time you saw a newsletter or press release on the lean sustaining system?

Secondly, the skills to run a lean management system are usually best taught by people who operated in lean management system in a prior job. This skill set is widely lacking world-wide. (even Toyota says this is one of their biggest risks) There are starting to be a few more books on the management system, but the approaches are far lacking in depth and volume from the operating systems tools/literature.

Third, when you are launching the new management system, most organizations fail to stop the old system. So an eager manager/change agent is forced to operate two systems. In reality, the longer the old system operates, the higher the likelihood of failure. It is simply too difficult, time consuming, and frustrating to operate with two management system (which are usually philosophically, diametrically opposed to one another). The inertia of the old system gradually pulls the organization back to status quo. The countermeasure to prevent this from happening is that senior leadership needs to provide some prioritization, direction, and top cover for the areas wanting to change. This includes the time and resources to deliver the breakthrough improvements and the time to deliver incremental improvement and sustain. 

There is a reason why only 3% of all organizations that start on a quality improvement journey get to world class. These organizations ensure the efforts of the management system as an equal ingredient in improvement success. 


 Lean Blessings:

Ron

Ron Bercaw, President and Sensei

www.breakthroughhorizons.com

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Go to Gemba

Image
  One of the tenants of continuous process improvement is to go to the workplace to see problems.   In lean terms, this is know as going to "gemba".  Gemba is a Japanese word that loosely translates to real-place  or the place that work is done.  In the western culture,  gemba is almost holy.  It is widely accepted as the source of all truth for seeing and eliminating wasted time and activity in the workplace.  This gemba term is accepted for both product and service industries and applies anywhere work is done. This blog is not about gemba, however,   but rather lack of gemba.   I am somewhere between concerned and appalled at the lack of gemba visits by both leaders and continuous improvement people alike. I'm sure this blog will not be popular with all readers, especially the firm "work from home crowd", but let me explain.  In the last two months alone I have personally encountered the following that impacted my clients ability to generate meaningful positiv
Read more

What happened to improving productivity?

Image
In my recent travels across the U.S,  I have been watching continuous improvement teams select measures for improvement.  Recall that by seeing and eliminating waste, we have the ability reduce defects, shorten lead-times, reduce cost, and grow our business.  I coach that every improvement project needs one key measure and the other measurement dimensions can be used as balancing measures.  Regardless of what we pick, when taking on a lean project we should always target 10% plus improvement. So why the blog?  What's happening?  In my recent surveillance, many organizations, particularly service organizations and public institutions are leaving cost off as a key measure.  Productivity is essential!  What exactly is productivity and why is it critical?  Productivity is the measure of how efficiently a process converts inputs into outputs. It is important for businesses and government institutions because it affects their profitability / budget, competitiveness, and customer satisfac
Read more

David Mann - One of the Kings of Visual Management

Image
On Dec 26, 2023, David Mann passed away.  For those of you that don't know, David was the author of the Shingo award winning book on using visual management to change culture.    His book, now in its third edition is shown here. The book is easy to find on either Amazon or Thrift Books.   In this book, David uses real examples from his time at Steelcase to show the elements of visual management and the behaviors needed to leverage all the good from this visual management. The book was a breakthrough for those wishing to understand visual management.  Let's spend a minute on visual management.  Unpacking this lean concept,  I coach that visual management is being able to discern normal from abnormal conditions at a glance so that an intervention can happen in real-time to keep things on track.   We want the workplace to talk to us through visual and audio clues.   In an business we want to know: 1. Are we ahead or behind? 2. Are we staffed appropriately? 3. Do we have enough to
Read more